Legacy Review
Souled Out '99
January 17, 1999 from the Charleston Civic Center in Charleston, WV
Commentary: Tony Schiavone, Bobby Heenan and Mike Tenay
As the calendar transitioned from '98 to '99 WCW underwent some major changes. First, at Starrcade Goldberg's undefeated streak came to an end. The giant, unexpected wave that helped keep WCW afloat the past year was no more. Then, on the first Nitro of '99, the Fingerpoke of Doom happened. Hollywood Hogan once again took the World title, the two NWO factions reunited to end their civil war that had also driven much of what happened in '98, and fans were generally furious at the World title being treated like a joke. The juxtaposition of the Fingerpoke of Doom against Mick Foley winning the WWF Championship for the first time on Raw the same night, a hugely popular win, could not be more stark.
About the only positive to speak of coming into the new year was the return of Ric Flair at Starrcade. He and Eric Bischoff had managed to smooth things over to the point they could at least work together again. In fact, thanks to Flair's victory over Bischoff in their rematch from Starrcade on the same Nitro as the Fingerpoke of Doom, Flair was now the on-screen President of WCW. As part of that, the co-branding of PPVs as "WCW/NWO presents" from the past year was now being phased out. The logos for this show had NWO crossed out in red paint, and starting next month at Superbrawl PPVs would be only under the WCW banner again.
The show opens with a "WCW Special Report" presenting a Flair presidential press conference. The main gist is WCW is once again a united front against the NWO. The stage design continues to trend more and more toward what WWF was doing, metal scaffolding structures and giant tron. During the (as usual for WCW overlong) balyhoo intro Tony gets interrupted by something happening in the back. We cut to "Star dressing room C" and see Goldberg on the floor holding his leg. He shouts "Get outta here!" and tosses a chair before we can learn anything else. My bet is on he headbutted his locker so hard it hurt his leg.
Chris Benoit def Mike Enos in 10:34- With Flair in charge the Four Horseman have officially reformed with Benoit once again part of the group. Enos was the longtime tag partner of Wayne Bloom (The Wrecking Crew in AWA and the Beverly Brothers in WWF), but after spending years as a jobber was getting a renewed mini-push teaming up with Bobby Duncam Jr as part of the lengthy ongoing tournament to determine new tag team champs. I'm not getting into that mess until I have to. The crowd is NUTS for Benoit. Lots of stalling at the start before a rough, roll around the ropes lockup. Benoit ducks a corner break cheap shot attempt and hits a chop. Enos turns him around and does a corner beatdown. Commentary is already completely checked out, talking about things coming later in the show rather than calling the match. Reset and Benoit gives Enos the vintage snot blow. Enos does an eye rake and hits a shoulderblock. He lets Benoit recover and plays to the crowd. Benoit slips out of a slam and hits another chop, followed by a clothesline. Corner chops and stomps. He catches an Enos kick and gives him a dragon screw. Another huge chop. Benoit ducks an Enos clothesline and goes for the crossface, but Enos blocks it and powers Benoit up into a gutwrench suplex. Powerslam for 2. Enos hooks on a bear hug for a bit, then drops Benoit in the corner. Benoit tries to kick back but Enos hits a clothesline and inverted atomic drop. Benoit manages to get a roll over sunset flip for 2. Enos grounds Benoit with a neck crank. Benoit dodges a legdrop. Enos hooks on the bear hug again. Benoit fights out but runs into a knee. Enos suplex for 2. Open hand slap exchange that wakes Benoit up. Benoit counters a back suplex into a cover for 2. ROOOOOLING GERMANS! Benoit only hits two. It's a B PPV. The headbutt off the top hits but both guys are down. Enos gets a back elbow and a clothesline. He hooks up for another suplex. Benoit counters into the crossface! Enos taps! That was a nicely intense, old school style match with a good story of Benoit slowly overcoming Enos' clear power advantage. Another good carry job by Benoit. ***1/4
Norman Smiley def Chavo Guerrero Jr in 15:44- Smiley carries an urn with him on his entrance. Commentary, via producers, says the remains of Chavo's stick horse Pepe are in there. This is the period where Chavo was a few beans short of a full burrito and they were basically trying to get him to do the same unhinged prop silliness that Al Snow was doing so well in WWF. Naturally it didn't work out quite as well for Chavo. Smiley taunts Chavo with some wood shavings out of the urn. More mocking and stalling before Chavo is finally close enough to hit some shots. After some back and forth Chavo 360 clotheslines Smiley to the floor. Plancha! Springboard bulldog back in. Smiley begs off and tights pulls Chavo into the corner. Chavo gets a springboard crossbody and hits a drop toe hold that I think was supposed to send Smiley into the bottom turnbuckle, but they were feet short so he faceplants the mat instead. Smiley hot shots Chavo in the corner and hits a corner clothesline. Classic Smiley windup slam and he teases doing the world famous wiggle. Chavo gets a flash cradle for 2. He blocks a Smiley roll up attempt and tries a splash but Smiley gets his knees up. Smiley suplex drops Chavo on the top rope. Gut stomp and he uses his legs to wrap Chavo up on the mat. One thing you can say in Smiley's favor, he was ZSJ like creative in his submission work. He just didn't know how to make it interesting or entertaining like ZSJ. As they grapple on the mat a decent portion of the crowd chants for Smiley. Chavo hits a clothesline. Smiley gets a running swinging neckbreaker for 2 before going back to the mat. Chavo tries to fight Smiley on his turf but Smiley quickly counters back on him. Both guys turn on the counter jets, ending with a Smiley back elbow. Stomps and an elbow drop from Smiley for 2. After a fight in the corner Smiley hits a superplex. Both guys are down. Smiley dances back up. He faceplant backdrops Chavo and hits a back elbow for 2. Sleeper from Smiley. Chavo tries to counter but takes a back suplex. After a Smiley corner beatdown Chavo dodges a charge in the corner. Backdrop for 2. Smiley hooks on a Gory Special. He blocks Chavo's counter cradle attempt, lifts him up into a wheelbarrow position, then spanks him! Chavo gets a counter roll up for 2. Victory roll from Chavo for 2. Chavo hits a running forearm in the corner. Smiley goes for his current top submission hold, a chicken wing, but Chavo fights it off. Chavo goes for his tornado DDT finisher but Smiley counters that. Smiley gets the urn out of his corner. He opens it up and tosses sawdust in Chavo's face! The chicken wing is on and Chavo taps out. For a Smiley match that wasn't too shabby, though it didn't sustain its length as well as it could have. **3/4
Fit Finlay def Van Hammer in 7:54- With the Flock done Hammer is now in his hippie phase. He's supposedly a face but he gets nothing from the crowd. Another slow start. Finlay cranks a headlock. Hammer hits a clothesline. Finlay works Hammer down to a knee and hits an elbow to the nose. European uppercuts. Short clothesline. Jawbreaker. He gives Hammer a couple of shots on the apron. Hammer slugs back and hits a backdrop. Finlay hooks on a nerve pinch and hits another nose elbow. Hammer supposedly hits a gut headbutt, Finlay sells it WAY more than it hit, and works on Finlay's knee a bit. After a long mat fight Hammer hits a jawbreaker. He baseball slides Finlay out to the floor. Finlay basement dropkicks Hammer off the apron. Hammer flips out of a Finlay sleeper and hits a corner clothesline. Big boot. Powerslam for 2. Rolling fireman's carry slam from Finlay. He hits a tombstone! That gets the pin. Finlay brought the usual intensity and carried Hammer as best he could. *1/4
Bam Bam Bigelow def Wrath in 9:23- Bigelow returned to WCW months ago as an occasional foil to Goldberg, but is only now getting his first PPV match back. Off the initial lockup Wrath shoves in the corner. Next lockup, Bigelow punches in the corner. Bigelow was slightly more effective. Wrath slugs back. He hits a bicycle kick and Bigelow rolls out. Back in Bigelow hits a shoulderblock but misses a diving headbutt. Wrath misses an elbow drop. Corner avalanche from Bigelow. Wrath hits a clothesline off the second rope for 2. Hot shot from Bigelow. After some more uninspired back and forth slugging Bigelow hits a clothesline. Slam/diving headbutt combo for 2. Bigelow hooks up a time killing chinlock. Since we're in that a long while, commentary starts discussing Bigelow's famous head tattoo. Heenan tells Tony to shave his head, get that tattoo, then grow your hair back and no one will know it's there. Fantastic. Wrath's comeback is killed with a back elbow. Dodge in the corner from Wrath and he hits a dropkick. Powerslam from Bigelow for 2. DDT for 2. Double clothesline and both guys are down. Bigelow dodges a corner charge, plants Wrath with Greetings from Asbury Park, and it's over. 3/4*
"The Total Package" Lex Luger def Konnan in 9:31- This is our first NWO match of the night. Soon after the reunion of the NWO factions the Wolfpac decided to kick Konnan out, with Luger delivering the message. Despite there only being one NWO again the Wolfpac's music is still being used. Luger takes a mic before the bell and offers Konnan an out. Konnan says no. With fists. Wild fists. Inverted atomic drop on Luger. Back elbow and Luger powders. Konnan tracks him down and brings him back. More pounding and Luger is selling pretty well, I'll give him that. He could be very prone to phoning it in. Luger dodges a dropkick and lays in a ton of stomps and slaps to huge boos. He works on Konnan's back. Konnan gives Luger a flurry of buckle shots but is soon down getting stomped on again. Konnan falls out to the floor. Back in Luger (barely) hooks on a bear hug. Konnan fights out but takes a clothesline. Luger hits a slam. Konnan rolls across the ring and completely ignores Luger's attempt to drop an elbow on him, then no sells it when Luger does. On the floor Konnan says something to Luger, then Luger gets in the ring and goes into stall mode. Konnan slowwwwwwwwwwly crawls his way back up into the ring. He gets boots up on Luger and hits a crossbody for 2. Rolling clothesline. Snap mare/dropkick combo with Konnan still only going about 50% of his usual speed, which isn't exactly lightning quick to start with. Elizabeth is coming out! While the camera is focused on her Konnan gets Luger in the Tequila Sunrise. Elizabeth sprays black paint in Konnan's face! Wait, they're Wolfpac. Shouldn't it be red? Anyway, Luger gets Konnan up in the Torture Rack and as always it's academic at that point. They had some good blood feud energy the first few minutes, but quickly burned through it and it devolved into a typical Konnan or late career Luger match. *
Loser Wears a Dress Match: Chris Jericho (w/Ralphus) def Perry Saturn in 11:44- Just like it says on the tin, whoever loses the match has to wear a dress. Ralphus comes out with a large paper bag that we assume the dress is in. Before the match starts commentary points out Scott Dickinson is reffing this match. He had been having issues with Saturn lately, seemingly egged on by Jericho. In other words, everyone can already see some variation of the finish coming. Lockup, Saturn hits a slap, and Jericho goes right out to the floor. Back in Jericho tights pulls Saturn down. He walks up the corner to keep Saturn in a headlock. Another walk up and this time Saturn tosses him away. Saturn ducks a clothesline and hits a back elbow. Jericho jawbreakers out of a chinlock. Saturn clothesline to Jericho's back. Ugly spin kick. Springboard legdrop for 2. Ralphus takes the dress out of the bag so the cameras, and Saturn, can get a look at it. Jericho gets a hot shot and springboard dropkicks Saturn to the floor. He slams Saturn on the floor. Delayed suplex back in. Arrogant cover! That sets Saturn off. Jericho gets a kick to the face and hits a senton for 2. Legdrop for 2. Slaps fire Saturn back up. Jericho punches him back down and goes for a quick Lionsault, but Saturn gets his knees up. Jericho comes off the second rope but gets caught into a Saturn exploder suplex. Saturn counters a Jericho corner flying headscissors attempt into a faceplant for 2. Jericho double underhook slam. Saturn dodges a dropkick and slingshots Jericho out to the floor! Baseball slide. Big splash off the top from Saturn back in for a long 2. After a long counter run, including some roll up counters, Jericho hits a bridged German suplex for 2. Saturn crotches Jericho on the top rope. He goes for a back superplex but Jericho flips over onto his feet. Jericho fights out of a DVD attempt. Saturn fights out of a Liontamer attempt. Jericho hooks up for a suplex. Saturn uses that to wrap up a small package. Dickinson then literally rolls them over so Saturn's shoulders are on the mat, then does a super fast 3 count. Yup, you saw that coming. Commentary says that was "maybe" a fast count. Give me a break, that was faster than one of Shane McMahon's fast counts. After the bell Jericho gives Dickinson the bag and slaps him, telling him to get Saturn in it RIGHT NOW. Dickinson gives Saturn the bag and Saturn, ex-Army Ranger tough guy, reluctantly dons the dress in an image for the ages. Jericho, Ralphus and Dickinson all leave together laughing. **1/4
Four Corners Match for the WCW Cruiserweight Championship: Billy Kidman (c) def Rey Mysterio Jr, Juventud Guerrera and Psychosis in 14:25- This is essentially a rematch of the three way at Starrcade with Psychosis added to the mix. This is under two guys start and you have to tag in and out rules, at least to start. Kidman and Mysterio, the two faces, "won" the coin toss backstage to get to start. The two heels, Juvy and Psychosis, try to interject themselves but get forced back to the apron by ref Lil' Naitch. Code of Honor handshake between Mysterio and Kidman and we're off. They go immediate speed and Mysterio hits a flying headscissors. After forcing the heels back again they hit the jets and have a big crossbody collision. Again the heels come in and try to stomp away on them. Mysterio has enough and tags Psychosis in. From the apron. Is that legal? Kidman then tags Juvy in from behind while Juvy's playing to the crowd. The heels shove each other and Psychosis gets the first shots in. Juvy does a victory roll for 2 with a Psychosis cradle counter for 2. Both guys trade chops. They have a bit of a fumbling exchange in the middle of the ring then go into some standing switches ending in a stalemate. They shake hands, hug, then both go to tag out but the faces hop off the apron! When Juvy and Psychosis' backs are turned they then run in and attack. Kidman and Mysterio hit some double teams on the heels. Kidman crossbody off the top on Psychosis for 2. Juvy trips Kidman into a Psychosis front suplex. Juvy flying headscissors off the top rope. Psychosis 360 clotheslines Kidman to the floor, then backdrops Mysterio onto him! Juvy and Psychosis go out, but then argue over who gets to hit the high spot. They start trading fists on the apron. The faces get up and sunset bomb them both to the floor! Kidman lifts Juvy up in the ring and Mysterio gives him a springboard doomsday device for 2. Mysterio and Psychosis fight on the apron. Mysterio monkey flips Psychosis over the corner to the floor! Kidman hits a senton off the top rope onto Psychosis on the floor. Juvy/Mysterio collision in the ring. Juvy lifts off Mysterio's back into a dive onto the others on the floor! Mysterio then does a tope con hilo over Lil' Naitch! The heels bail and Kidman takes the whole thing. Then Juvy accidentally clotheslines Psychosis on the floor. The teamwork portion of the match is over now, it's become a straight four way with no one worrying about tagging or who's legal. Which I won't complain about because this is how a four way should be. Mysterio hits what would become the west coast pop on Juvy in the ring. Juvy reverses into a cradle for 2. Juvy hits the Juvy driver, but Psychosis breaks the pin up with a missile dropkick to Juvy. Psychosis reverse hurricanrana off the top to Juvy. Kidman counters into a faceplant on Psychosis. Mysterio hits a bulldog on Psychosis. Psychosis clotheslines Juvy and Kidman to the floor, then slides Mysterio out. Juvy sets up the faces laying down on the floor. Psychosis tope con hilo onto them! Juvy hits a missile dropkick on Psychosis in the ring. Mysterio dodges a Psychosis dive on the floor. Meanwhile, Kidman has Juvy set up in the ring. The shooting star press hits, and that gets the pin to retain. The breakdown of the match from teams to everyone for themselves was fun, but apart from that it was pretty much a spotfest like the Starrcade match. ***1/4
"Nature Boy" Ric Flair and David Flair (w/Arn Anderson) def Curt Hennig and Barry Windham in 13:56- This is all part of the Flair vs NWO battle, with the NWO SUPER pissed Flair took Bischoff out of power. Windham had recently returned to WCW and was logical to throw in here as another guy, like Hennig, that had extensive history with Flair. This is also the very first recorded match for Flair's 19 year old son David, who initially didn't want to be a wrestler but had recently changed his mind. I'm honestly not sure how much formal training he'd had before this, but one look at him and you can pretty much guess not much. If any. Essentially this is Erik Watts 2.0. Lots of words are exchanged on the mic before the match, including Flair threatening Hennig with banishment to WWF if he didn't get in the ring. I can't see how that'd be a threat considering where the two companies were at this point. Windham then demands David starts with him. David talks his dad into it. David's wrestling in a tshirt and shorts. He goes right for a leg takedown that Windham easily avoids. Windham grabs a headlock. David muffs a headscissors counter, but Windham sells and bails anyway. Ric hops in and struts around like something good actually happened. As always, credit to him for trying to make the best out of it. Windham uses a test of strength to get a kick in. David slips out of a slam, hits chops and a hiptoss. Windham comes back with a slam but misses an elbow drop. David mercifully tags right out to his dad. Corner chops and jabs on Windham. Hennig comes in and takes a chop with a huge Hennig sell. Ric backdrop on Windham. Hennig tags in throwing chops. Ric eye pokes him and hits another huge chop, then an elbow to Hennig's knee. Hennig is trying to throw in as much classic over the top Hennig selling as he's physically capable of anymore. Hennig does the snap mare/neck snap combo, then chops David off the apron. Corner whip and Ric does the Flair Flip to the floor! Windham hops down to give him chops and a guardrail shot. Back in Ric back elbows Hennig, then makes the mistake of going up top and gets slammed off. Windham hits the superplex for 2. Arn and Hennig stand off on the floor. Ric counters Windham mounted punches into an inverted atomic drop. Hennig comes in and starts working on the knee. Corner beatdown and Flair Flop! Hennig hooks on a figure four with leverage help from Windham. Windham tags in and continues the knee work. He goes for a figure four but Ric small packages him for 2. He tries to come back but Windham eye pokes him and we continue with Ric in peril. He ends up in the wrong corner again. Arn drags Hennig out and lays into him! Ric back suplexes Windham and hooks the figure four on! Hennig takes Arn out then breaks the hold up. The heels hook up for a double suplex. David comes in and low blows Hennig! Ric small package on Windham for 2. Hennig drags David in and goes for the perfectplex on him. Arn gets in behind him, whacks him in the back of the head with the tire iron that was his thing at this point, and David literally falls on top of Hennig to get the pin. The kid just had to get the pin. Dumb booking and David looking more lost than Bronny James in an NBA game aside, the bulk of the match when David was parked on the apron wasn't too shabby because everyone else had their working boots on, even if they weren't as physically capable as they used to be. Hennig and Windham were pulling stuff out of parts of the tank I didn't even think they had left. The Flair effect. **1/2
After the bell the NWO run in, and I mean the WHOLE NWO. Wolfpac, Hogan, everyone. They handcuff Ric to the ropes then proceed to beat David in front of him while Ric looks on bawling. It goes on for so long the crowd chants for both Goldberg and Sting but of course neither show up. They spraypaint "EZE", Bischoff's nickname, on David's back before leaving. This is nowhere near over, but I hope you're ready for nonsensical swerve heel turns because, boy, we've got one coming up here.
Stun Gun Ladder Match: Goldberg def Scott Hall in 17:45- It was a shot from Scott Hall with one of the Mountie's old shock sticks that cost Goldberg the World title and the streak to Kevin Nash at Starrcade, so this is Goldberg looking for revenge while also trying to start a new streak. "Who's next" has turned into "Who's first". That's not me, that's literally what Goldberg's saying. Listening to Buffer trying to get through the rules for this match is freaking hilarious. It doesn't matter who retrieves the stun gun that's hung up where a title belt would normally be in a ladder match, it's whoever uses the gun to ZAP his opponent that will be the winner. Hall kills time cutting an entire promo before the match. He tries to claim Goldberg can't wrestle due to the attack at the start of the show, but of course 20 seconds later here's Goldberg is making his way out. He does have a knee brace on. Lots of stalling at the start. Hall shoves. Goldberg shoves harder. Easy lockup win for Goldberg. Hall bounces off Goldberg trying a shoulderblock. Eye poke from Hall and he starts the usual arm work, until Goldberg clotheslines him. A Hall slam attempt goes nowhere. Goldberg hits a slam but has to shake his bad knee off. Hall kicks the leg. Goldberg shrugs it off and hits a powerslam, but is still favoring the knee. Now Hall really starts to go to work on it. Apron and post shots for the knee. Hall goes over to get the ladder. Goldberg cuts him off. While stepping backward Goldberg literally legit trips over the ladder. He tosses Hall back in the ring and limps back to get the ladder. Hall baseball slides the ladder into Goldberg. Stair shot and Goldberg is busted open. Blood on a Turner show! Time for the cameras to go wide for the rest of the match. Hall sets the ladder up and climbs. He stops decides to drop an elbow on Goldberg from the ladder, but he puled the ladder too and it comes down on top of him! Hall climbs again. Goldberg comes behind and back suplexes him off the ladder. Hall picks the ladder up and runs it into Goldberg, then drops it on him. Another Hall climb. Goldberg pushes it over and Hall goes into the ropes. Hall tries to run the ladder into Goldberg but Goldberg cuts it off with a clothesline. Hall sets the ladder up in the corner. Goldberg reverses a whip and Hall goes into the ladder. Now it's Goldberg's turn to give Hall some ladder shots. Goldberg climbs. Hall dropkicks the ladder to knock him off! Then he pushes the ladder down onto Goldberg. Hall slow climbs while Goldberg wanders around the ring. Finally Goldberg pushes the ladder over again. Goldberg climbs and is almost there. Here come the run ins. Disco Inferno is out and pushes the ladder down. Goldberg falls THROAT FIRST RIGHT INTO THE TOP ROPE! His head snapped back hard when he hit it. That was completely unintentional and could have been really, really bad. Reminds me of Enzo Amore throwing himself into the bottom rope and damn near killing himself one of his first WWE main roster matches. Disco gets Hall up. He climbs and gets the taser. Goldberg dodges it, then fights Hall off. Superkick from Goldberg. The taser bounces out to the floor. Goldberg gets his feet caught in the ladder and literally falls out of the ring going to get it. Damn this this has been sloppy. Disco takes a nice casual taser shot, like Goldberg barely knew he was there. Goldberg gets back in. Hall begs off. More standing there taking forever. Goldberg tosses the taser up like a jump ball. When Hall leaps for it Goldberg spears him! Jackahmmer! After more moment milking there's the taser shot and it's over. Bigelow runs in and beats Goldberg down. Hall then zaps BOTH guys because why not. And just like that the show ends incredibly abruptly. It shows 2:55 on the runtime so clearly they didn't want to go over again like Halloween Havoc. That was like watching a ladder match underwater. **1/4
OVERALL SHOW THOUGHTS- The very definition of a filler, mostly skippable B PPV. There's nothing truly horrendously awful, which is a borderline miracle for WCW, but there's also nothing significantly good and only the David Flair beatdown and maybe the main event and, sadly, Saturn in a dress can claim any kind of long term significance.
OVERALL SHOW GRADE: D+